Time is the scarcest resource on most LP teams. Manager universes keep growing, virtual meetings make it easier than ever to fill a calendar, and headcount rarely keeps pace. So we asked several senior institutional LPs, off the record, a basic question: where does your time go that it shouldn’t? Their answers were candid and likely familiar to anyone who has sat through the last 52 minutes of a pitch they mentally rejected in the first eight. What follows, in their own words, is the first in what we hope will be a regular series of anonymous insights from our industry members.
Macroeconomic Analysis
Studying and discussing macroeconomic conditions can be very intellectually stimulating for LPs. We have access to high-quality, robust data and some of the smartest investors on the planet! Talking about macro conditions and listening to others make predictions about the future is exciting because the future is so uncertain. That said, when was the last time someone presented information on GDP growth, inflation, tariffs, elections, or employment statistics, and it led you to make a different decision in your PE portfolio? We’ve never adjusted our annual PE pacing or commitment targets because someone was bearish on US GDP growth. Have you? If so, how often have you made adjustments based on macro data? Did it meaningfully impact your performance? We also spend time in our diligence memos highlighting macroeconomic conditions. When I’m reading a diligence memo written by another team member, I often find myself skimming the macro section, glancing at the charts, and moving on. I have never read a macro section in our memos and thought: “this section was critical to my supporting a new commitment to this fund.” This includes what I’ve written for funds I’ve led! It makes me wonder why I feel the need to spend hours compiling “insightful” macroeconomic data for a memo when it has little impact on the decision.
The one caveat on macro is valuation. There have been a few times in the past 15 years that understanding current valuations compared to historical levels resulted in us buying or selling fund interests in the secondary market or committing additional capital to a strategy or region. It’s also worth noting that sometimes we use the word “macro” to include both macroeconomic and microeconomic factors. We have found that microeconomic factors, especially sector conditions, have an impact on our PE decision-making. So maybe the conclusion is that we should focus our macro analysis on valuations and use the time saved to provide more robust microeconomic analysis? While the study of macroeconomic conditions can be fun, I often wonder if there are higher-value ways to spend our time.
Standard 1-Hour Intro Meetings
Most LP-GP intro meetings follow a well-worn pattern – firm history, team bios, philosophy, process, portfolio, etc. Such intro calls provide the opportunity for an LP to hear these basics directly from the GP. Often, after reviewing a deck or a teaser, an LP may think a manager is worth additional work, and it is only in the process of asking follow-up questions and hearing more specific details that an LP can decide whether to advance to further due diligence.
One of the standard things about such meetings is that they typically are booked for one hour. This might have made sense in the past, when in-person meetings were also standard. However, post-COVID, the use of virtual meetings has exploded, resulting in far more intro meetings overall. Many LPs have gone from one intro meeting per day to multiple meetings per day. Assuming an extra 3-5 meetings per week, an LP will spend an additional 150-250 hours per year in meetings with prospective GPs. If an LP is meeting with 500 funds per year and making 10 commitments, there is a great deal of time spent on meetings that do not progress to a recommendation. Reducing the number of hours spent on those meetings that don’t make the cut creates immediate resource gains.
Perhaps the easiest way to reduce the time lost in these meetings is to schedule intro meetings for 30-45 minutes instead of an hour. There is nothing that can be accomplished in an hour-long call that can’t be done in 45 minutes; longer, more detailed discussions of process and case studies should be reserved for on-site or follow-up due diligence. These intro calls are almost always pass/fail as far as moving a manager forward. Of course, GPs generally would prefer the longer time because it gives them more time to build a relationship, engage in small talk, etc., but at this stage, these aren’t value-added activities for the LP.
If the agenda for these calls were focused on our needs, 30-45 minutes would surely suffice. Candidly, it sometimes becomes all too apparent very quickly that a given manager should not advance to the next stage, but decorum prevents most LPs from simply ending the meeting or call after eight minutes. However, it would certainly be easier to sit through the rest of the call if we knew we only had 37 minutes left to go instead of 52.
PMEs on Every Fund?
Fund-level Public Market Equivalent (“PME”) analysis is a useful tool for evaluating how private equity buyout funds stack up against public equity markets. Because PE investments are illiquid and long-term, standard metrics like internal rate of return (IRR) and multiple on invested capital (MOIC) don’t fully capture the opportunity cost of choosing private markets over public ones. PME bridges this gap by offering a more direct comparison. This allows us to assess whether a fund’s performance justifies the added complexity, fees, and illiquidity inherent in private investments.
While PME analysis is a standard part of our fund underwriting, it’s not something we spend a lot of time debating during investment committee meetings. Our investment committees are specific to each asset class strategy. We operate under the assumption that the overarching asset allocation decision has already been made at a higher level. The asset allocation target, combined with our pacing analysis, shapes our specific deployment goals for PE. Given these strategic directives, our PE team’s core mission is identifying and backing the top-performing managers, believing that their alpha generation will ultimately drive superior returns for our portfolio. Therefore, our primary focus is on relative peer performance. If PME rarely changes your decision, maybe it would be more effective to run a quick PME pass/fail screen at the beginning of your review process rather than spending a lot of time during diligence? Or maybe ask the GP to provide the analysis? If you find that 99% of GPs you review outperform public markets, then maybe eliminating the PME analysis altogether would save you some time?
Asking Lawyers to Negotiate with Other Lawyers
The legal negotiation process between an LP and a GP on a fund works like this: lawyers representing the LP review fund documents and send proposed comments to the LP. The LP then approves or rejects each comment. The LP’s lawyers send the approved comments to the GP’s lawyers. Those comments are discussed with the GP and accepted or rejected. The rejected comments are sent back to the LP’s lawyers and the process starts again. The lawyers on both sides are paid by the hour, which gives neither side much incentive to be efficient. Have you ever wondered why organizational fees and internal legal fees keep increasing even when this is your third, fourth, or fifth fund with the same GP? Due to this dynamic, we’ve started negotiating more directly with the GP. By communicating directly with the GP on the key outstanding legal terms rather than through lawyers, we’ve found the legal process to be more efficient and less costly.
Our Take-away
The common thread isn’t laziness; it’s habit. Each of these activities feels productive but rarely changes a decision. The best LPs aren’t the ones who work the most hours – they’re the ones who know which hours don’t count.